Comparison of the three methods for pregnancy detection in Iraqi Sheep
A. M. F. Al-Mohammedy1 and Y. T. Abdul-Rahaman1,*
1 College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Fallujah, Iraq.
* Correspondence: [email protected].
Available from. http://dx.doi.org/10.21931/RB/2023.08.03.125
Twenty Iraqi ewes aged between 2-3 years were used in the current study. All animals were raised in an animal field belonging to the Fallujah in the Saqlawiyah area from August 2022 to February 2023. It was fed naturally, and on one diet and T1 Control, T2 was given hCG- COX 100 IU/ ewe injection, T3 was given Biotin 10 mg/ ewe/ daily oral, and T4 was given Biotin 10 mg/ ewe/ daily oral + hCG- COX 100 IU/ ewe injection. After mating, blood samples for progesterone and Sheep Pregnancy Associated Plasma Protein B (PAPPB) measurements were collected on Days 48 and 79. The study's results showed accuracy when diagnosing pregnancy by the PAPPB method, which was 100% during the 48th and 79th day of pregnancy—followed by the method of diagnosis by ultrasonography. Hence, the progesterone assay method. At the same time, specificity was superior in the PAPPB method. The accuracy of pregnancy diagnosis between PAPPB and ultrasonography on day 48 of pregnancy was equal. While there were no results during the diagnosis using progesterone assay. In conclusion, the pregnancy diagnosis by PAPPB is considered one of the most accurate and modern methods.
Keywords: Pregnancy detection; progesterone; ultrasonography; PAPPB; Iraqi Sheep.
Livestock contributes a large percentage to the agricultural sector, around 50% to most countries. This wealth is essential in the national income of many countries, and livestock is meant to be raised cattle, sheep, goats, buffaloes, camels, horses, poultry and fish. Concerning sheep, they have an essential role in the economies of many countries, past and present, and are mainly raised for the production of meat, wool, milk, and leather3. Early diagnosis of pregnancy in sheep has an essential role in the economy of countries to reduce increased expenses on the herd and exclude sick animals 4. The method of diagnosing progesterone is one of the primary methods for diagnosing pregnancy in animals, including sheep, as the high concentration of the hormone in the blood or milk is considered an indication of the presence of pregnancy due to the presence of the corpus luteum.
Nevertheless, sometimes, the diagnosis cannot be considered correct in this way due to early embryonic death and the survival of the corpus luteum in the secretion of progesterone. Therefore, the diagnosis of pregnancy by ultrasonography method was essential in detecting pregnant females on the 21st day of pregnancy, but this method requires an experienced person and a high cost. The PAPPB method is a modern and accurate method for detecting pregnancy in sheep at an early stage of pregnancy through placenta formation. Early detection of pregnancy reduces the expenses, costs and effort of the farmer while excluding sick animals, increasing the productivity and fertility of the herd1,2,11,15,16,17,20. This field study aimed to compare the accuracy of progesterone, ultrasonography and PAPPB test for early pregnancy detection in Iraqi Sheep.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Twenty Iraqi ewes aged between 2-3 years with body weight between 34-48 kg were used in the current study. All animals were raised in an animal field belonging to the Fallujah in the Saqlawiyah area between August 2022 and February 2023. The animals were isolated for 30 days before the study began and were examined by the ultrasonography apparatus to ensure they were not pregnant. The animals were divided randomly into 4 equal groups. It was fed naturally and on one diet and the first group (T1) Control, the second group (T2) was given hCG- COX 100 IU/ ewe injection, the third group (T3) was given Biotin 10 mg/ ewe/ daily oral (30 days) and the fourth group (T4) was given Biotin 10 mg/ ewe/ daily oral (30 days) + hCG- COX 100 IU/ ewe injection. Estrous synchronization is unified by placing vaginal sponges for 13 days.
After mating, blood samples for progesterone and Sheep Pregnancy Associated Plasma Protein B (PAPPB) measurements were collected on Days 48 and 79. The blood was centrifuged at 4000 rpm for 15 minutes. The plasma was collected in sterilized plastic tubes and kept at -20°C. Progesterone concentrations were measured by COBAS (E-411). The kit provided by Roche, Inc., Switzerland, and Sheep Pregnancy Associated Plasma Protein B (PAPPB) concentrations were measured using ELISA technology—the kit provided by Sunlong Biotech Co., Ltd, China. The indices were determined as Positive predictive value: 100 × a/a + b; Negative predictive value: 100 × c / c + d; Sensitivity: 100 × a/a + d; Specificity: 100 × c / c + b; Accuracy (%) = (a +c/ a + b + c + d) ×100.
Between days 48 PM (16 ewes) and 79 PM (20 ewes), were declared pregnant using the progesterone assay. The sensitivity of progesterone assay for detecting pregnant ewes increased from 76.47 to 100% during the experimental period. The sensitivity of progesterone assay for detecting pregnant ewes decreased accuracy (65%) at day 48 PM and increased accuracy (85%) at day 79 PM. The specificity of the progesterone test in detecting non-pregnant ewes on days 48 and 79 was equal (0%). A similar trend was observed for positive predictive values, which decreased progressively from 81.25% at day 48 PM, which increased again at day 79 PM to 85%. On the contrary, the negative predictive value of this test for the detection of non-pregnant females was equal at day 48 PM and day 79 PM. Better results were obtained for detecting pregnant and non-pregnant ewes using the ultrasonography technique Fig (1). The sensitivity for detecting pregnant ewe was high (94.12%) at day 79 PM and moderately accurate (76.47%) at day 48 PM Fig (2). The specificity (%) for detecting non-pregnant ewe obviously from 66.67% at day 79 PM Fig (3), and 100% during day 48 PM. The positive predictive value (%) for detecting the pregnant ewe was increased (100%) at day 48 PM and lower at day 79 PM (94.12%). In contrast, negative predicting values were lower (42.86%) at day 48 PM and higher (66.12%) at day 79 PM. Accuracy decreased (80%) at day 48 PM and increased (90%) at day 79 PM. The results of the current study showed the compatibility between accuracy, specificity, sensitivity, and predictive value of positive and negative tests during the test periods days 48 and 79 using the PAPPB method (100%) (Table 1).
Figure 1. Ultrasonogram of the ewe before treatment
Figure 2. Ultrasonogram of the ewes at day 48 PM
Figure 3. Ultrasonogram of the ewes at day 79 PM
Table 1. Early pregnancy detection of ewes using three different methods
The plasma progesterone assay is often the method for early pregnancy detection. This method is accurate and can be done for the second week of pregnancy15.
Karen et al.11 found that sensitivity (100%), specificity (95.4%), positive (81.6) and negative (100%) predictive values for progesterone at day 18 after AI.
Ganaie et al.7 noted that the accuracy of detecting pregnancy at 100 % and non-pregnancy at 83.3% was the same for days 15-30 and 31-45 of pregnancy, And the accuracy of 98%, prediction values of 97.7 and 100% for positive and negative detection, at days 18.23±0. 78. The researcher also showed that the determination of progesterone hormone by ELISA on the 18th day after fertilization is considered one of the reliable methods for diagnosing pregnancy in Corriedale ewes.
The difference in results may be due to the difference in the sensitivity of the progesterone test. Affects: irregularity of the estrous cycle, early embryonic deaths, ovarian and ovarian pathological conditions like hydrometra, pyometra and luteal cysts as the result of hormone concentration8.
The results of the current study did not agree with this as it was found that sensitivity (95.2%), specificity (100%), positive predictive value (100%), negative predictive value (80%) and accuracy (96%) and 19, noted that sensitivity 91.30%, specificity100%, positive predictive value 100%, negative predictive value ration 83.3% for pregnancy examination findings by transabdominal ultrasonography on days 34- 35.
Ultrasonography is used to detect pregnancy in a variety of domestic species, such as ewes. The use of ultrasonography has proven effective for the examination of ovarian follicles, corpora lutea and pregnancy. Genetic factors and nutrition affect the process of diagnosing pregnancy in ewes by ultrasound, and the placenta and its development6 determine the gestational age.
Studies have shown that the optimum time for transabdominal or transrectal ultrasonography in ewes ranges from 12- 23 days PM may correctly predict approximately 85% of pregnant sheep and by 40 days using external trans-abdominal. The sex is determined between 60-69 days, as the accuracy was (100%) for males but only (76%) for female fetuses. The number of fetuses can be counted accurately from about 45 to 100 days of gestation. So detection is usually undertaken between the 12- 13 weeks after insemination5, 14. The diagnosis was made on day 16. The accuracy was 50%, whereas at day 23 (72.73%) and day 30 (90.91%)12.
Age affects the sensitivity of the test by ultrasonography, as it increases in young ewes and decreases in older ewes on the 40th day of pregnancy; in addition, the examination method, whether external or internal, affects the accuracy of the ultrasonography result17,18.
Embryo development can be divided into three periods: First period, initial attachment of the blastocyst; second period, The embryonic period extends from day 12 to day 34 in the ewes. In this period, growth and differentiation occur, during which the significant tissues, systems and organs are established and the significant features of the external body form. The third period, the fetal period, extends from about day 34 of gestation in ewes until birth. Growth and changes in the form of the fetus characterize this period. Species, breed, and strain differences in fetal size are due to differences in the rate of cell division, which is determined genetically. Thus, there is close integration between the feed supply to the fetus (environmental factors), the rate of cell division (genetic factors), and hence, the rate of growth9.
The current study agreed with the analysis of 13, showing that pregnancy can be diagnosed by the PAPPB method on the 45th day of gestation in ewes.
PAPPB are significantly higher in sheep-carrying twin than in those carrying singles because the PAPPB are secreted by binucleate cells, which represent 15–20% of fetal placental cells, and the total placental masses was higher areas of contact between the fetal placenta and maternal caruncles than those in sheep carrying singles10.
In conclusion, the pregnancy diagnosis by PAPPB is considered one of the most accurate and modern methods, followed by ultrasonography and progesterone assay. In sheep, pregnancy can be clearly and accurately diagnosed by ultrasound on the 48th day of pregnancy.
1. Akköse, M. Evaluation of a bovine rapid visual PAG ELISA test and transabdominal ultrasonography for early pregnancy diagnosis in Awassi Sheep. KSU Journal of Agriculture & Nature. 2020, 23 (5): 1366-1372. doi:10.18016/ksutarimdoga.vi.668707
2. Alkan, H.; Kivrak, M. B.; Satilmis, F.; Tekindal, M. A. and Dinc, D. A. Detection of twin pregnancies in ewes by pregnancy-associated glycoprotein assay and transabdominal ultrasonography. Domestic Animal Endocrinology. 2020, 72: 106399.doi: 10.1016/j.domaniend.2019.106399
3. Alkass, J. E.; Hermiz, H. N. and Baper, M. I. Some aspects of reproductive efficiency in Awassi ewes: A review. Iraqi Journal of Agricultural Sciences. 2021, 52(1): 20-27.doi: 10.36103/ijas.v52i1.1232
4. Andueza, D.; Alabart, J. L.; Lahoz, B.; Muñoz, F. and Folch, J. Early pregnancy diagnosis in sheep using near-infrared spectroscopy on blood plasma. Theriogenology. 2014, 81 (3): 509- 513.doi: 10.1016/j.theriogenology.2013.10.016
5. Bragança, G. M.; Balaro, M. F. A.; Fonseca, J. F.; Pinto, P. H. N.; Rosa, R. M.; Ribeiro, L. S.; Almeida, M. S.; Souza Fabjan, J. M. G.; Garcia, A. R. and Brandao, F. Z. Doppler ultrasound in the diagnosis of early pregnancy in sheep. Animal Reproduction. 2016, 13 (3): 587.
6. Othman Ghazi Najeeb Alani , Yassen Taha Abdul-Rahaman and Thafer Thabit Mohammed. Effect Of Vêo® Premium and Vitamin C Supplementation on Lipid Profile Before and During Pregnancy in Some Local Iraqi Ewes During Heat Stress. Iraqi Journal of Science.2021, Vol. 62, No. 7, pp: 2122-2130.
7. Ahmad, A. Sh., F.T. Al-Rawi, Y.T. Abdul-Rahaman, TH. T. Mohammed, K.I. Mahmud. Effect of Tryptophan injection on the semen quality in Iraqi Shami buck. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2021, 761(1), 012093.
8. Ishwar, A. K. Pregnancy diagnosis in sheep and goats: a review. Small Ruminant Research. 1995, 17: 37- 44.
9. Jainudeen, M. R. and Hafez, E. S. E. Gestation, prenatal physiology, and parturition. In: Reproduction in farm animals. Hafez, B. & Hafez, E. S. E., Part. 2, Chapter 10, 7th ed., Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, U.S.A. 2000, P. 147.
10. Karen, A.; Amiri, B. E.; Beckers, J. F.; Sulon, J.; Taverne, M. A. and Szenci, O. Comparison of accuracy of transabdominal ultrasonography, progesterone and pregnancy-associated glycoproteins tests for discrimination between single and multiple pregnancy in sheep. Theriogenology. 2006, 66(2): 314- 322.doi:10.1016/j.theriogenology.2005.11.017
11. Tatar , A.; Kasaeizadeh, . R. .; Shobeirinia, B. .; Abdali, . L. .; Baeelashaki, R. . The Effect Of Using Different Levels Of Vitamin E On The Productive Traits Of Broiler Chickens. JLSAR 2023, 4, 30-36
12. Metodiev, N.; Dimov, D.; Ralchev, I. and Raicheva, E. Efficiency of transrectal ultrasonography for pregnancy diagnosis of Ile de France ewes during the first month of gestation. Bulgarian Journal of Veterinary Medicine. 2017, 20 (3): 276- 280.doi:10.15547/bjvm.944
13. Pickworth, C. L.; Sheffield, J. and Poole, R. K. Pregnancy specific B concentration for the prediction of lambing rate in sheep. Small Ruminant Research. 2020, 184: 106052.doi:10.1016/j.smallrumres.2020.106052
14. Zain, H.; Tatar , A.; Alabi, O. M. .; Samiei Zafarghandi, M. . The Effect Of Using Different Levels Of Vitamin E On The Antioxidants Status Of Broiler Chickens. JLSAR 2023, 4, 37-44..
15. Purohit, G. Methods of pregnancy diagnosis in domestic animals: The current status. Webmed Central Reproduction. 2010, 1(12)WMC001305: 1- 28.
16. Rovani, M. T.; Cezar, A. S.; Rigo, M. L.; Gasperin, B. G.; Júnior, J. E. D.; Torres, F. D.; Gonçalves, P. B. D. and Ferreira, R. Evaluation of a bovine pregnancy-associated glycoprotein enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit for serological diagnosis of pregnancy in sheep. Ciência Rural, Santa Maria. 2016, 46 (2): 362- 367.doi:10.1590/0103-8478cr20150270
17. Tavana, M.; Peighambarzadeh, S. Z. and Bardshiri, B. Evaluation of Pregnancy Detection in Lori-Bakhtiari Sheep by Transrectal Ultrasonography. International Journal of Advanced Biological and Biomedical Research. 2014, 2 (7): 2268-2270.
18. Taverne, M. and Noakes, D. E. Pregnancy and its diagnosis. In: Reproduction and Obstetrics. Noakes, D. E.; Parkinson, T. J. and England, G. C. W., Part. 1, Chapter 5, 10th ed., Elsevier. 2019, P. 101 -102. doi:10.1016/C2014-0-04782-X
19. Tekin, T. C. and Köse, A. M. Investigation of the effectiveness of ultrasonography in determining pregnancy and the number of fetuses on the 35th day of pregnancy in Awassi sheep. Journal of Advances in VetBio Science and Techniques. 2022, 7(2): 143-152.doi:10.31797/vetbio.1091526
20. Yotov, S. and Sinapov, B. Effect of GnRH administration on Pregnancy- Associated Glycoproteins in dairy sheep with different reproductive status. Acta Scientiae Veterinariae. 2023, 51 (1920): 1- 8.doi:10.22456/1679-9216.129955.
Received: 25 June 2023/ Accepted: 26 August 2023 / Published:15 September 2023
Citation: Al-Mohammedy A. M. F. , Abdul-Rahaman Y. T. Comparison of the three methods for pregnancy detection in Iraqi Sheep. Revis Bionatura 2023;8 (3) 125 http://dx.doi.org/10.21931/RB/2023.08.03.125